1. |
- Essner, Ann, 1971-
(författare)
-
On assessment methods related to pain in dogs with osteoarthritis
- 2018
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- There is a need of valid and reliable assessment methods that are clinically applicable in canine rehabilitation practice. The aim of this thesis was to psychometrically evaluate measurement properties in assessment methods related to pain in naturally occurring canine osteoarthritis. Assessment methods developed for heart rate variability analysis, i.e. Polar heart rate monitor, and owner-reported perceptions of pain severity and pain interference with functionality, i.e. Canine Brief Pain Inventory, were tested.Methods: Four observational studies were conducted. Study I was a cross-sectional study consisting of two groups of consecutively recruited dogs. The Canine Brief Pain Inventory was administered to owners of dogs with naturally occurring osteoarthritis (n=61) and clinically sound dogs (n=21). Study II was a descriptive and correlative cross-sectional study based on the same sample of dogs with osteoarthritis (n=71), assessing chronic pain behavior and associations between explanatory variables and chronic pain behavior. Study III and IV were correlative studies, assessing Polar heart rate monitor measuring interbeat intervals and time- and frequency-based heart rate variability parameters, compared to simultaneously recorded electrocardiogram in dogs (n=11).Results: High internal consistencies and ability to discriminate sound dogs from osteoarthritis dogs were found. The hypothesis of the presented two-factor structure of the Canine Brief Pain Inventory was rejected. Owners reported higher proportions of chronic pain behavior in items targeting physical activities, e.g. getting up, moving after rest and moving after major exercise. A minor proportion of dogs with osteoarthritis showed no owner-perceived behavioural signs of chronic pain. Owner observations were not associated with ongoing antiinflammatory medications. In Study III and IV, 595 errors (12.3%) were identified in Polar data. The number of errors were unequally distributed among the dogs. Interbeat intervals and heart rate variability parameters from electrocardiogram and Polar were strongly associated. Standard error of measurements were high among some heart rate variability parameters in Polar and electrocardiogram.In conclusion, this thesis contributes to our knowledge about assessment methods related to diverse components of pain in dogs with osteoarthritis, allowing improved pain management in clinical practice.
|
|
2. |
- Hedman, Ragnhild, 1962-
(författare)
-
Striving to be able and included : Expressions of sense of self in people with Alzheimer's disease
- 2014
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- According to research applying a social constructionist perspective, the sense of self is not lost in people with Alzheimer’s disease (AD). It is, however, greatly influenced by the symptoms and by how they are treated by other people. Without support, it is difficult to preserve a positive sense of self, when living with progressing cognitive impairments. The stigma associated with cognitive impairment also threatens their sense of self. Harré’s social constructionist theories of self and positioning have been used to study how people with AD express their sense of self. As there is a need to expand the previous research by involving additional participants and research contexts, the aim of the present thesis was to describe, in accordance with Harré’s theories of self and positioning, how people with AD expressed their sense of self in personal interviews and in support groups with other people with AD. The research consists of four substudies (I–IV), and has a qualitative, descriptive, and theory-testing approach. Thirteen people with mild and moderate AD were included, 11 of whom had the early onset form of the disease. Two support groups were formed, led by facilitators who supported the communication and the participants’ expressions of self. Each group met 10 times during an eight-month period. Topics were not predetermined, and introduced by both facilitators and participants. Semistructured interviews were conducted before the groups started and after they ended. The interviews and support group conversations were audio-recoded and analysed with qualitative content analysis, guided by Harré’s theories. In substudy I, the initial interviews were deductively analysed. The findings showed that Self 1 (the sense of being a singular, embodied person) was expressed by the participants without difficulties. Self 2 (the perception of one’s personal attributes and life history) was expressed as feeling mainly the same person. While some abilities had been lost, other had been developed. Self 3 (the socially constructed self) was described as mostly supported, but sometimes threatened in interactions with other people (I). In substudy II, support group conversations were analysed abductively with respect to expressions of Self 2. It was found that participants expressed Self 2 in terms of agency and communion, and a lack of agency and communion (II).In substudy III, a secondary analysis of the data from substudy II was performed inductively with the aim of describing how Self 3 was constructed in the interaction of the support group. Five first-order positions, generating lively interaction, were described: the project manager, the storyteller, the moral agent, the person burdened with AD, and the coping person (III). In substudy IV, all the collected data were reanalysed inductively, focusing on how participants expressed the experience of being research participants. Three themes were constructed: contributing to an important cause, gaining from participating, and experiencing risks and drawbacks (IV). In conclusion, it was found that participants constructed positive social selves through the support from each other, the facilitator, and researchers in the support group (III), and as research participants (IV). Agency and communion were central to Self 2, and decreased with the progression of AD (II). In spite of change, participants perceived themselves as basically the same people, with a potential to learn and develop as persons (I).
|
|
3. |
- Holmlund, Lena, 1967-
(författare)
-
Patients’ experiences of atrial fibrillation and an evaluation of a nurse-led person-centred clinic
- 2024
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- Background: Living with and managing atrial fibrillation (AF) can be complex. Some people have no symptoms, while others have a significant symptom burden. Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is often low and partly associated with symptom burden. However, the impact of the condition on daily life differs between those affected and is not fully understood. Therefore, more knowledge is needed about patients’ experiences of AF and factors influencing HRQoL. Research indicates that the care of patients with AF needs to change and be more based on personal preferences and values.Aim: The overall aim of this thesis was to explore patients’ experiences of AF and to evaluate the effects of a nurse-led, person-centred clinic.Methods: The thesis contains four studies. Study I was based on interviews with 15 patients about their experiences of living with symptomatic AF. Studies II and III were based on data from questionnaires completed before and 6 months after scheduled electrical cardioversion. Study II was a cross-sectional study with 52 women and 115 men describing illness perceptions and HRQoL and exploring their relationship. Study III was a longitudinal study comparing 53 newly diagnosed (<6 months) and 76 previously diagnosed patients with AF (≥6 months) regarding HRQoL, illness perceptions, symptoms, symptom burden, anxiety and depression. Study IV was a randomised controlled trial evaluating the effects of a nurse-led, person-centred clinic on patient-reported outcomes measures in patients with AF. Patients were randomly assigned to a nurse-led intervention group (n=50) or a control group with a physician visit (n=53) and completed questionnaires on the same subjects as in Study III at baseline before the visit to the clinic and 6 months after. Study I were analysed with qualitative content analysis. The other studies are quantitative and were analysed with descriptive statistics (Studies II–IV), comparative statistics (Studies II–IV), and correlation analysis and multiple linear regression analysis (Study II).Results: In Study I, three themes (striving for illness control, becoming a receiver or an active partner in care, and dealing with a changed self-image) were reflected in the main theme, balancing life. The participants described their struggles in understanding AF, preventing recurrence and managing anxiety. Some were not involved in decision-making, lacked continuity of care, felt that most information focused on medical issues and requested more support and self-care advice. Study II showed that HRQoL was related to and negatively affected by attributing more symptoms, severe consequences, and negative emotions (e.g., anxiety, anger) to AF and perceiving AF as recurrent. Women reported worse HRQoL and lower personal control than men. Study III showed that newly diagnosed (vs. previously diagnosed) patients at baseline reported AF as a more temporary condition to a greater extent and had stronger belief that the illness was controllable. After 6 months, newly diagnosed patients reported better HRQoL, higher personal control, and lower symptom burden than previously diagnosed patients. Over time, HRQoL improved and AF symptom burden and symptoms of anxiety decreased in newly diagnosed patients, who viewed the illness as chronic to a greater extent than at baseline. Study IV showed that, in the nurse-led intervention group, the patients’ negative emotions towards AF decreased more than in the control group. In addition, their concerns regarding AF decreased and their personal control increased. In both groups, HRQoL and patients’ understanding of AF improved.Conclusions: This thesis demonstrates that for many, AF meant a change in life in which they had to manage anxiety and symptoms and oscillate between being strong and weak and a changed self-image. Men (vs. women) and newly diagnosed (vs. previously diagnosed) patients reported more positive outcomes, such as better HRQoL and greater belief in their ability to control AF. Worse HRQoL was associated with negative illness perceptions, such as more perceived recurrences, symptoms, severe consequences, and negative emotions. The findings in Study IV suggest that the support from a nurse-led person-centred clinic may reduce patients’ negative emotions and concerns attributed to AF and improve their personal control.
|
|
4. |
- Tuvemo Johnson, Susanna, 1964-
(författare)
-
Falls and fall prevention in community-dwelling older adults
- 2018
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- Falls are the primary cause of injuries among older adults, and accidents that result from falls can lead to personal suffering and extensive societal burdens. The overall aims of this thesis were to explore and describe falls and fall prevention strategies in community-dwelling older adults and to evaluate a fall prevention home exercise program, the Otago Exercise Program (OEP), with or without motivational interviewing (MI).Methods: Qualitative and quantitative research methods were uses. The designs were as follows: a cross-sectional, descriptive and comparative study (study I); a descriptive feasibility investigation (study II) and a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with two interventions, the OEP and OEP+MI, as well as a control group, with a 12-month follow-up (study III); and a prospective and descriptive study (study IV). The four studies comprised community-dwelling individuals aged 75 years or older. Study I included 262 individuals and studies II-IV had 175 participants who needed walking aids or home support. Study II also included 12 physical therapists. Data collection was performed via self-reported questionnaires, fall calendars, exercise diaries, physical performance tests and a semi-structured questionnaire. Results and conclusions: Suggested actions to prevent falls significantly differed between high and low active older adults (study I). Support for self-directed behavioral strategies could be important for preventing falls in older adults who have low physical activity levels. The study protocol for the RCT had acceptable feasibility (study II), and only minor changes of the protocol were needed. There were no benefits for OEP or OEP+MI with personal support implemented nine times over the 12-month period. However, all groups maintained physical functioning and activity (study III). To increase physical functioning and reduce falls in this sub-group of older adults, more frequent personal support and/or an alternative delivery format may be required for efficient intensity and challenge in home exercises. Over 12 months, falls and fall-related injuries in the RCT sample were the most common when moving around within the home and transitioning from sitting to standing (study IV). Special attention to these activities might be important for preventing falls in community-dwelling older adults who need walking aids or home support.
|
|
5. |
- Eckerblad, Jeanette, 1966-
(författare)
-
Symptom burden among people with chronic disease
- 2015
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- Introduction: Chronic diseases tend to increase with old age. Older people with chronic disease are commonly suffering from conditions which produce a multiplicity of symptoms and a decreased health-related quality of life. Nurses have a responsibility to prevent, ease or delay a negative outcome through symptom management, or assist in achieving an acceptable level of symptom relief.Aim: The overall aim of the thesis was to describe different aspects of symptom burden from the perspective of community-dwelling people with chronic disease.Methods: This thesis is based upon four papers that used both quantitative and qualitative data to describe different aspects of symptom burden, experienced by people with chronic diseases. Paper (I) is a cross-sectional study with 91 participants diagnosed with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Papers (II and IV) are based upon secondary outcome data from a randomized controlled trial with 382 community-dwelling older people with multimorbidity. Paper (II) is a cross-sectional study and Paper (IV) has a descriptive and an explorative design reporting on the trajectory of symptom prevalence and symptom burden. Paper (III) is a qualitative study with participants from the AGe-FIT.Results: Among people diagnosed with COPD the most prevalent symptoms with the highest symptom burden scores were shortness of breath, dry mouth, cough, sleep problems, and lack of energy, with just a few differences between participants with moderate and severe airflow limitation (I). For older people with multimorbidity, pain was the symptom with the highest prevalence and burden. Other highly prevalent symptoms were lack of energy and a dry mouth. Poor vision, likelihood of depression, and diagnoses of the digestive system were independently related to the total symptom burden score (II). The symptoms experienced by the older people were persistent and the symptom burden remained high over time (IV). The experience of living with a high symptom burden was described as an endless struggle. The analysis revealed an overall theme, “To adjust and endure” and three sub-themes, “to feel inadequate and limited”, “to feel dependent”, and “to feel dejected” (III).Conclusions: The results of this thesis indicate the importance of early symptom identification. People with chronic diseases have an unmet need for optimized treatment that focuses on the total symptom burden, and not only disease specific symptoms. A large proportion of older people with multimorbidity suffer a high and persistent symptom burden, and the prevalence and trajectory of pain are high. Older people sometimes think their high age is the reason they experience a diversity of symptoms, and they do not always communicate these to their health-care provider.
|
|
6. |
- Ericsson, Iréne
(författare)
-
Välbefinnande och demens : Aspekter på välbefinnande hos äldre personer med måttlig till svår demens
- 2011
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- Personer som lever med demenssjukdom såväl som mentalt friska människor behöver uppleva välbefinnande. Ett viktigt mål i vården och omsorgen av personer med demens är därför att hitta vägar för att försöka främja välbefinnande hos personen. Avhandlingens övergripande syfte varatt utveckla kunskap om aspekter av betydelse för att äldre personer med måttlig till svår demens ska uppleva välbefinnande. Avhandlingen baseras på empiriskt material från fyra delstudier. Den första delstudien, I(etnografi) genererade fältanteckningar från 31 observationstillfällen samt nio kvalitativa intervjuer med vårdgivare, så kallade kontaktmän till personen med demens. Delstudie II(testutveckling/tvärsnittsstudie) utgjordes av 336 testprotokoll som bearbetades statistiskt. Materialet i delstudie III (reformulerad grundad teori) innefattade 18 kvalitativa intervjuer med personer med demens samt 18 observationsprotokoll från observation av icke-verbalt språk. Den sista delstudien (IV) (konstruktivistisk grundad teori) bestod av fältanteckningar från 24 videoinspelningar av Egentids-situationer och 24 kvalitativa intervjuer med personer med demens samt åtta kvalitativa intervjuer med vårdgivare. Resultatet från avhandlingens studier visar att de kognitivt friska personerna som finns i personens närhet har en avgörande betydelse för upplevelsen av välbefinnande hos personer med måttlig till svår demens. För att interaktion ska vara önskvärd och ge välbefinnande måste den mentalt friska parten ha kunskap och insikt om att det finns en större medvetenhet hos personen med måttlig till svår demens än vad det omedelbara intrycket av förmågor ger. Om denna insikt saknas finns risk att interaktionen kan leda till kränkning i stället för välbefinnande. Det är förmodligen av betydelse att ha kunskap om och försöka fånga personens kvarvarande förmågor istället för att fokusera på brister. Kunskap om kvarvarande förmågor och till exempel överinlärda förmågor som fångas i anpassade test kan bidra till en mer positiv syn på personen och innebära att kvarvarande förmågor bättre tas tillvara, vilket kan bidra till välbefinnande. Personen med måttlig till svår demens kan kommunicera ett välbefinnande men det kräver lyssnarens förmåga och förmåga att tolka. Det kan också kräva en del praktiska ansträngningar med hänsyn till personens kognitiva nedsättningar som till exempel hjälpmedel i form av bilder och ting. Förmodligen ger interaktion som leder till en relation alltid en upplevelse av välbefinnande. Tid är en avgörande faktor för att upprätta relationer som ger välbefinnande hos personer med måttlig till svår demens. Det är därför viktigt att i vården avsätta tillräcklig tid, som vid till exempel Egentid, för att upprätta relationer och därigenom främja välbefinnande.
|
|
7. |
- Pohl, Petra, 1965-
(författare)
-
Falls in older community-dwelling women and men : risk factors and safety strategies. Fall risk awareness, fear of falling, and preferred exercise properties from a gender perspective.
- 2015
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- Background Falls are the leading cause for non-fatal injuries in older community-dwelling people. Compared to men, women fall more often, experience more fall-related injuries, and report fear of falling (FoF) more often. Falls may be prevented with specific exercises, but adherence is often low in long-term. One aim of the thesis was to gain a deeper understanding of the risk factors previous falls, FoF, and gender. Another aim was to explore safety strategies in older community-dwelling people in terms of fall risk awareness and actions taken to protect from falls, and to identify motives for exercising and preferred exercise properties. A gender perspective was used throughout the thesis.Methods To determine the impact of the risk factors on future falls and injurious falls, a cross-sectional design was used combined with longitudinal data. Baseline data from 230 community-dwelling people over 75 years were collected with questionnaires and performance-based tests. FoF was measured with the single item question “Are you afraid of falling?”. Monthly fall calendars were collected for one year (monitoring year). Based on status on falls, participants were classified as those with i) no falls (n=119), ii) 1 non-injurious fall (n=51), iii) ≥2 non-injurious falls (n=40), and iv) ≥1 injurious fall (n=20). These data were linked to data from an injury database (IDB) with respect to registered injurious falls for a period of about 5 years (long term follow-up). Andersen-Gill method of Cox regression for multiple events was used to estimate the risk of future injurious fall events. To find relationships between FoF, gender, and falls (defined as two or more falls), a general log-linear analysis was performed. Associations between FoF and the components of the International Classification of Functioning (ICF) were explored with a structural equation model. To explore fall risk awareness and safety strategies, and to identify motives and preferred exercise properties, qualitative study design was used. Multistage focus groups were held with 18 community-dwelling people (10 women and 8 men) between 70 and 80 years. Transcriptions were analysed with qualitative content analysis.Results Fourty-eight per cent of the 230 participants fell at least once during the monitoring year, and 23% experienced recurrent falls. Compared to men, women reported FoF more often, but did not experience more recurrent falls, and no more injurious falls. FoF was significantly associated with the ICF components Activity/Participation and Personal Factors in women and men both; but in opposite directions for women and men on Personal Factors. During the long-term follow-up, 91 injurious falls were registered in 70 participants (30%). Those with injurious falls during the monitoring year were at significant risk of experiencing new injurious falls in long-term (HR 2.78; 95% CI 1.40-5.50), compared to those with no falls. Women experienced a higher rate of fractures than did men. Analyses from the multistage focus groups resulted in three categories: Facing various feelings; Recognizing one’s fall risk; and Taking precautions. A comprehensive theme tied them together: Safety precautions through fall risk awareness. Analyses also resulted in six categories identifying preferred exercise properties in the context of falls prevention: Motives to start exercise; Barriers to start exercise; Exercise characteristics; Confirmation; Spirit lifters; and Maintenance tricks. All categories included sub-categories. Both studies revealed greater variations among women and among men than between women and men.Conclusion Community-dwelling people over 75 years who have experienced an injurious fall are at high risk of sustaining new injurious falls the forthcoming five years, and should be offered multifactorial fall risk assessments with targeted interventions to optimize the prevention of future falls. The single item question “Are you afraid of falling?” has no predictive value for future falls, and the answer may be strongly gendered. The questions should therefore be avoided in clinical practice and research in community settings. The participants of the qualitative studies implicity and explicitly described how they had become aware of fall risks in everyday life, and both women and men took precautionary actions. Raised fall risk awareness was achieved by several channels including the media, and by meeting with peers and professionals with expertise in falls prevention. A wide variety of preferred exercise properties in the context of falls prevention were identified among the older community-dwelling people. The variations of the requests were greater among women and among men than between women and men. The results should be taken into consideration when offering exercise-based falls prevention interventions to older people. The results from this thesis indicated that measures can be taken on a broad front in order to reduce the damage from injurious falls in older community-dwelling people. A gender perspective is warranted for in clinical practice and future research. Adopting a gender perspective may broaden the understanding of gender differences and similarities when implementing falls prevention activities.
|
|
8. |
- Sondell, Anna, 1968-
(författare)
-
Exercise and team rehabilitation in older people with dementia : applicability, motivation and experiences
- 2019
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- The world’s population is aging. With the growing population of older people, dementia disorders are becoming increasingly common. Dementia disorders are progressive and include impairments in cognitive and physical function, which lead to increased risks of inactivity, falls, fractures, and comorbidity. Dementia is also the leading cause of dependency in activities of daily living. Therefore, rehabilitation including exercise is needed for this population. To obtain optimal effects on the functional ability of older people, exercise should be task specific, functional, performed at high intensity at sufficient frequency and duration, and include both balance and strength training. Motivation to participate is important for exercise program participation, the fulfillment of exercise recommendations and facilitation of motor learning in order to achieve exercise response. However, exercise recommendations for older people are based mainly on findings from studies conducted with people without dementia. Exercise may be challenging for some people with dementia due to complicating symptoms, such as cognitive deficits, depression, apathy or lack of motivation, and behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD). Studies exploring the applicability of exercise programs have been called for to optimize exercise programs; knowledge about motivation is lacking, and how this together influences exercise response in this group. Additionally, dementia disorders significantly affect all aspects of life for the affected persons and their informal caregivers, friends, and family members in their immediate networks. Furthermore, the care and rehabilitation needs of community-dwelling people with dementia must be considered due to the decreasing proportion of nursing home residents in Sweden today. Scientific knowledge and clinical experiences regarding the use of interdisciplinary team rehabilitation for people with dementia are limited, despite the urgent need for rehabilitation and its proven effects after events such as hip fracture. The effects of person-centered multidimensional interdisciplinary rehabilitation programs for people with dementia, including education and counseling for informal primary caregivers, have not been evaluated and need to be explored.The overall aim of the thesis was to evaluate exercise and team based rehabilitation among older people with dementia. Specifically, the objectives were to evaluate motivation to participate in and applicability of a high-intensity functional exercise program, and to explore participants’ experiences with a multidimensional interdisciplinary team rehabilitation program including high-intensity functional exercise, among older people with dementia.In the Umeå Dementia and Exercise (UMDEX) study, a cluster-randomized controlled trial including 186 people with dementia in nursing homes, the effects of the High-Intensity Functional Exercise (HIFE) Program and a seated social activity, both lasting for 45 minutes and held five times fortnightly for 4 months, were compared. Participants’ motivation to go to activity sessions and motivation during sessions were assessed using a five-point Likert scale. The applicability of the exercise program (with regard to attendance, achieved intensity, and adverse events) was assessed with a focus on dementia type and reasons for non-attendance and for not achieving high intensity, based on exercise diary data. Balance exercise response was investigated using the Berg Balance Scale, assessed at baseline and 4 month follow-up. In the Multidimensional InterDisciplinary Rehabilitation in Dementia (MIDRED) study, a randomized controlled study, a person-centered multidimensional interdisciplinary rehabilitation program for community-dwelling older people with dementia, including education and counseling for informal primary caregivers, was evaluated. With the aim of exploring experiences with program participation, 16 participants with dementia were interviewed and data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis.The UMDEX study showed that motivation during activities was quite high, with no overall difference between groups; over time, however, motivation increased in the exercise group and decreased in the social activity group. Motivation during activity sessions was greater than motivation to go to sessions in both groups. The exercise program was applicable, with high attendance rates, moderate to high intensity achieved, and the occurrence of only minor and temporary adverse events. Dementia subtype, low motivation, pain, and presence of BPSD seemed to affect applicability. The exercise response varied widely, with many participants showing improved balance after the intervention. The applicability of the exercise program and motivation did not seem to be associated with paramount balance response. Four categories emerged from the MIDRED study analysis: being empowered through challenges; gaining insight, motives and rising concerns about the future; to participate is worthwhile, if you are seen; and togetherness in prosperity and adversity.In conclusion, for older people with dementia living in nursing homes, who have a high prevalence of medical conditions and functional limitations, motivation to participate in a high-intensity exercise program was high and did not differ from motivation to participate in a less physically demanding social activity. The exercise program seems to be applicable with regard to attendance, achieved intensity, and adverse events. The prediction of balance exercise response based on program applicability and participant motivation does not seem to be possible. The promotion of strategies to encourage people with dementia to join exercise groups is of great importance, and more knowledge about strategies is needed to overcome low pre-exercise motivation levels. An interdisciplinary rehabilitation program for community-dwelling older people seems feasible, according to reported experiences. The participants had positive experiences and perceived improvement and empowerment due to the rehabilitation, which can influence well-being in daily life in this population. The results of this research support the inclusion of this population in team rehabilitation and high-intensity functional exercise programs.
|
|
9. |
- Wiberg, Sofia, 1977-
(författare)
-
Lyssnandets praktik : Medborgardialog, icke-vetande och förskjutningar
- 2018
-
Doktorsavhandling (övrigt vetenskapligt/konstnärligt)abstract
- I dialogforskning och planeringspraktik pekas det ofta på vikten av att skapa fler forum för att ”ge röst” till invånargrupper i syfte att skapa mer politiskt jämlika processer, stärka demokrati och social hållbarhet (Abrahamsson, 2015) samtidigt som mindre fokus sätts på de praktiker och vanor som avgör vad som kan höras. Det är en omöjlighet att lyssna på allt, ett lyssnande innebär därmed alltid ett sorterande där vissa saker får utrymme och annat blir bortsorterat (Palmås och von Bush, 2015). Lyssnandet har samtidigt inte fått lika mycket uppmärksamhet som något politiskt utan har oftare förknippats med något passivt, till skillnad från rösten och språket som är förknippat med akten att skriva, läsa eller tala. Lyssnandet faller därför lätt in i en förenklad binaritet mellan aktivitet eller passivitet vilket har hindrat lyssnandet att betraktas som en politisk handling (Lacey, 2014). Med detta som utgångspunkt ser jag det som centralt om vi vill ge utrymme för fler erfarenheter, att inte endast fokusera på att bjuda in marginaliserade invånare till gängse dialogforum utan även problematisera själva forumen och ramarna för dialogen, att vända blicken mot planerare, arkitekters och tjänstepersoners arbetssätt och rutiner, och reflektera över hur de påverkar vad som kan höras. Utgångspunkten för avhandlingen är mina personliga erfarenheter som processledare för två dialogprocesser: en kommunal medborgardialogsprocess som jag genomförde i Botkyrka kommun – Samtal om framtiden mellan 2011-2012 – samt det utforskande konst- och forskningsprojektet Rehearsals - åtta akter om lyssnandets politik som genomfördes tillsammans med Petra Bauer och en grupp på Tensta konsthall 2013-2014 där vi gemensamt prövade olika sätt att föra dialog med varandra bortom orden. Avsikten är att belysa den mer röriga och komplexa praktiken snarare än att lyfta fram framgångshistorier. Syftet med avhandlingen är att utforska lyssnandets roll i ledandet och organiseringen av dialogsituationer för att bidra med förhållningssätt till dialoger för att möjliggöra det politiska att framträda. Centrala begrepp i avhandlingen är 1400-talsfilosofen Nicholas Cusanus ratio och intellectus, som beskrivning av två delar av vårt förnuft. Genom ratiot förhåller vi oss till livet som ett pussel där vi genom att mäta, räkna och kalkylera försöker hitta givna svar. Genom intellectus förhåller vi oss närmare icke-vetandet och ser att ratios kategorier aldrig är helt uttömmande och att det vi kallar för värld är i ett ständigt skapande (Bornemark, 2017). Ett lyssnande genom intellectus, såsom jag beskriver det i avhandlingen, skapar möjlighet för det som flera politiska filosofer på lite olika sätt benämner som ”det politiska”, forum där det spontana, oregerliga och störande kan ta plats och politiska frågor väckas (Rancière, 2009, Mouffe, 2008). Enligt Hannah Arendt (1958) är en förutsättning för att det politiska ska äga rum att det finns ett visst mått av oförutsägbarhet. Om vi vill lyssna kan vi i förhand inte bestämma oss för vad vi vill höra, vi behöver öppna upp för att bli överraskade av det vi hör.
|
|