SwePub
Sök i LIBRIS databas

  Utökad sökning

WFRF:(Kenter Jasper O.)
 

Sökning: WFRF:(Kenter Jasper O.) > What does value plu...

  • Isacs, Lina,PhDUppsala universitet,KTH,Hållbarhet, utvärdering och styrning,Department of Earth Sciences, Climate Change Leadership, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden,Institutionen för geovetenskaper,KTH Royal Inst Technol, Dept Sustainable Dev Environm Sci & Engn SEED, Stockholm, Sweden. (författare)

What does value pluralism mean in practice? An empirical demonstration from a deliberative valuation

  • Artikel/kapitelEngelska2023

Förlag, utgivningsår, omfång ...

  • 2022-04-17
  • Wiley,2023
  • printrdacarrier

Nummerbeteckningar

  • LIBRIS-ID:oai:DiVA.org:su-204943
  • https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:su:diva-204943URI
  • https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10324DOI
  • https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:kth:diva-322989URI
  • https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-501798URI

Kompletterande språkuppgifter

  • Språk:engelska
  • Sammanfattning på:engelska

Ingår i deldatabas

Klassifikation

  • Ämneskategori:ref swepub-contenttype
  • Ämneskategori:art swepub-publicationtype

Anmärkningar

  • QC 20230620
  • The intensified call for value pluralism within research on valuation in environmental decision-making responds to the recognition that neoclassical economic approaches to environmental valuation do not sufficiently account for important aspects of human–nature relations. However, few studies have explored how value plurality actually plays out in social deliberative reasoning and decision-making in practice, and these studies have mostly been deductive and quantitative.In his essay ‘Are choices trade-offs?’ Alan Holland (2002) goes to the heart of differences in conceptions of value and rationality between neoclassical and ecological economics. These conceptions differ in terms of whether values are seen as commensurable or incommensurable, whether people's choices amount to willing exchanges of gains and losses between different values and whether unwillingness to trade values off for net gain is irrational.Addressing Holland's question, we present a quasi-experimental study on deliberative valuation of marine issues on the Swedish west coast, where we considered how local citizens and politicians approached values in their reasoning and choice-making. Mixing quantitative and qualitative empirical material, we used an abductive analytical approach, iterating between data and theory to link our observations and interpretations to prevalent understandings of value, valuation and deliberation in the literature.The results demonstrate the relevance of value pluralism for environmental policy by showing the prevalence of preference uncertainty and intrapersonal value conflicts in participants' reasoning and interaction. Value conflicts played out as the inability to achieve multiple transcendental values that participants aspired to, including conflicts between social and environmental goals. Rather than attempting to commensurate different value dimensions, participants sought to avoid moral conflicts, showed emotional anguish when value conflicts came to the fore and tried to bridge conflicting aspirations and experiences through inclusive reason-giving and compromise.Thus, choices were not resolved through rational trade-offs, supporting Holland's claim and challenging the neoclassical trade-off model of choice. Incommensurability appeared as deliberate positions grounded in participants' experiences rather than as irrationality. Legitimately resolving value conflicts thus demands reason-sensitive means for deciding upon the sacrifices to be made and supporting public participation in environmental decision-making in ways that reveal peoples' actual moral considerations.

Ämnesord och genrebeteckningar

Biuppslag (personer, institutioner, konferenser, titlar ...)

  • Kenter, Jasper O.Ecologos Research, Borth, United Kingdom;Department of Environment and Geography, University of York, York, United Kingdom,Ecologos Res, Borth, Wales.;Univ York, Dept Environm & Geog, York, N Yorkshire, England. (författare)
  • Wetterstrand, HannaStockholms universitet,Stockholm Resilience Centre,Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden,Stockholm Univ, Stockholm Resilience Ctr, Stockholm, Sweden.(Swepub:su)hwett (författare)
  • Katzeff, Cecilia,Associate professor,1957-KTH,Strategiska hållbarhetsstudier,KTH Royal Inst Technol, Dept Sustainable Dev Environm Sci & Engn SEED, Stockholm, Sweden.(Swepub:kth)u1viejrx (författare)
  • KTHHållbarhet, utvärdering och styrning (creator_code:org_t)

Sammanhörande titlar

  • Ingår i:People and Nature: Wiley5:2, s. 384-4022575-8314

Internetlänk

Hitta via bibliotek

Till lärosätets databas

Kungliga biblioteket hanterar dina personuppgifter i enlighet med EU:s dataskyddsförordning (2018), GDPR. Läs mer om hur det funkar här.
Så här hanterar KB dina uppgifter vid användning av denna tjänst.

 
pil uppåt Stäng

Kopiera och spara länken för att återkomma till aktuell vy