Sökning: WFRF:(Christ B) > Many Labs 5: Testin...
Fältnamn | Indikatorer | Metadata |
---|---|---|
000 | 15929naa a2202341 4500 | |
001 | oai:hhs.se:1156422330006056 | |
003 | SwePub | |
008 | 230125s2020 | |||||||||||000 ||eng| | |
024 | 7 | a https://research.hhs.se/esploro/outputs/journalArticle/Many-Labs-5-Testing-Pre-Data-Collection-Peer/9910014895993060562 URI |
024 | 7 | a https://doi.org/10.1177/25152459209586872 DOI |
040 | a (SwePub)hhs | |
041 | a engb eng | |
042 | 9 SwePub | |
072 | 7 | a art2 swepub-publicationtype |
072 | 7 | a ref2 swepub-contenttype |
100 | 1 | a Ebersole, Charles R.u University of Virginia (United States, Charlottesville) - UVA4 aut |
245 | 1 0 | a Many Labs 5: Testing Pre-Data-Collection Peer Review as an Intervention to Increase Replicability |
264 | 1 | b Sage,c 2020 |
520 | a Replication studies in psychological science sometimes fail to reproduce prior findings. If these studies use methods that are unfaithful to the original study or ineffective in eliciting the phenomenon of interest, then a failure to replicate may be a failure of the protocol rather than a challenge to the original finding. Formal pre-data-collection peer review by experts may address shortcomings and increase replicability rates. We selected 10 replication studies from the Reproducibility Project: Psychology (RP:P; Open Science Collaboration, 2015) for which the original authors had expressed concerns about the replication designs before data collection; only one of these studies had yielded a statistically significant effect (p < .05). Commenters suggested that lack of adherence to expert review and low-powered tests were the reasons that most of these RP:P studies failed to replicate the original effects. We revised the replication protocols and received formal peer review prior to conducting new replication studies. We administered the RP:P and revised protocols in multiple laboratories (median number of laboratories per original study = 6.5, range = 3-9; median total sample = 1,279.5, range = 276-3,512) for high-powered tests of each original finding with both protocols. Overall, following the preregistered analysis plan, we found that the revised protocols produced effect sizes similar to those of the RP:P protocols (Delta r = .002 or .014, depending on analytic approach). The median effect size for the revised protocols (r = .05) was similar to that of the RP:P protocols (r = .04) and the original RP:P replications (r = .11), and smaller than that of the original studies (r = .37). Analysis of the cumulative evidence across the original studies and the corresponding three replication attempts provided very precise estimates of the 10 tested effects and indicated that their effect sizes (median r = .07, range = .00-.15) were 78% smaller, on average, than the original effect sizes (median r = .37, range = .19-.50). | |
650 | 7 | a SAMHÄLLSVETENSKAPx Sociologix Socialpsykologi0 (SwePub)504032 hsv//swe |
650 | 7 | a SOCIAL SCIENCESx Sociologyx Social Psychology0 (SwePub)504032 hsv//eng |
700 | 1 | a Mathur, Maya B.u Stanford University (United States, Stanford) - SU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Baranski, Ericau University of Houston (United States, Houston) - UH4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bart-Plange, Diane-Jou University of Virginia (United States, Charlottesville) - UVA4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Curran, Paul G.u Grand Valley State University (United States, Allendale) - GVSU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Day, Chris R.u Coventry University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Dering, Benjaminu University of Stirling4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Dreber, Annau Stockholm School of Economics,Handelshögskolan i Stockholm4 aut0 (Swepub:hhs)1274@hhs.se |
700 | 1 | a Edlund, John E.u Rochester Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Falcao, Filipeu University of Porto4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Fedor, Annau Centre for Ecological Research4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Feinberg, Lilyu Boston College4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ferguson, Ian R.u Virginia Commonwealth University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Pienkosz, Damianu Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Preti, Emanueleu University of Milano-Bicocca4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Puric, Dankau University of Belgrade4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ravid, Jonathanu Boston College4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Razza, Timothy S.u Nova Southeastern University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ramos, Tiagou University of Porto4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Rentzsch, Katrinu Psychologische Hochschule Berlin4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Richetin, Julietteu University of Milano-Bicocca4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Rife, Sean C.u Murray State University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Saunders, Blairu University of Dundee4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Sawicki, Przemyslawu Kozminski University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Dalla Rosa, Annau University of Padua4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Rudy, Kaylis Haseu Brigham Young University - Idaho4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Salamon, Janosu Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Schmidt, Kathleenu Southern Illinois University Carbondale (United States, Carbondale) - SIU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Wood, Michael J.u University of Winchester (United Kingdom, Winchester)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Zealley, Davidu Brigham Young University - Idaho4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Zezelj, Irisu University of Belgrade4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Nosek, Brian A.u University of Virginia4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Zrubka, Marku University of Amsterdam4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ford, Maireu Loyola Marymount University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Schulz-Hardt, Stefanu University of Göttingen4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Schuetz, Astridu University of Bamberg4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Shabazian, Ani N.u Loyola Marymount University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Shubella, Rachel L.u Rose–Hulman Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Schuepfer, Kurtu Miami University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Schultze, Thomasu University of Göttingen4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Frank, Michael C.u Stanford University (United States, Stanford) - SU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Fryberger, Emilyu Pacific Lutheran University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Garinther, Alexanderu University of Oregon4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Gawryluk, Katarzynau Kozminski University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Silva, Rubenu University of Porto4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Siegel, Adamu Cultivate Labs, Chicago, IL USA4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ashbaugh, Kaylau Rose–Hulman Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Giacomantonio, Maurou Sapienza University of Rome4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Giessner, Steffen R.u Erasmus University Rotterdam4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Grahe, Jon E.u Pacific Lutheran University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Guadagno, Rosanna E.u Stanford University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Halasa, Ewau Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Sioma, Barbarau Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Skorb, Laurenu Boston College4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Cunha de Souza, Luana Elayneu Universidade de Fortaleza4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Steegen, Sarau KU Leuven (Belgium, Leuven) - KUL4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Stein, L. A. R.u University of Rhode Island4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Sternglanz, R. Weylinu Nova Southeastern University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Hancock, Peter J. B.u University of Stirling4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Hilliard, Rias A.u Rose–Hulman Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Hueffmeier, Joachimu TU Dortmund University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Hughes, Seanu Ghent University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Idzikowska, Katarzynau Kozminski University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Inzlicht, Michaelu University of Toronto (Canada, Toronto)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Stojilovic, Darko4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Storage, Danielu University of Denver (United States, Denver)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Sullivan, Gavin Brentu Coventry University (United Kingdom, Coventry)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Szaszi, Barnabasu Eötvös Loránd University (Hungary, Budapest) - ELTE4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Szecsi, Peteru Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Szoke, Orsolyau Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Szuts, Attilau Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Jern, Alanu Rose–Hulman Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Jimenez-Leal, Williamu Universidad de Los Andes (Colombia, Bogotá)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Thomae, Manuelau MEU Multiversitat, Magdeburg, Germany4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Tidwell, Natasha D.u Fort Lewis College4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Tocco, Carlyu Queens College, CUNY4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Johannesson, Magnusu Stockholm School of Economics,Handelshögskolan i Stockholm4 aut0 (Swepub:hhs)198@hhs.se |
700 | 1 | a Joy-Gaba, Jennifer A.u Virginia Commonwealth University (United States, Richmond) - VCU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kauff, Mathiasu Supreme Council Of Health4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kellier, Danielle J.u University of Pennsylvania4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kessinger, Greciau Brigham Young University - Idaho4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kidwell, Mallory C.u University of Utah (United States, Salt Lake City) - UU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Torka, Ann-Kathrinu TU Dortmund University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Vianello, Michelangelou University of Padua4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Viganola, Domenicou Stockholm School of Economics,Handelshögskolan i Stockholm4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Vlachou, Mariau KU Leuven4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Tuerlinckx, Francisu KU Leuven (Belgium, Leuven) - KUL4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Vanpaemel, Wolfu KU Leuven (Belgium, Leuven) - KUL4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Vaughn, Leigh Annu Ithaca College (United States, Ithaca)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kimbrough, Amanda M.u The University of Texas at Dallas4 aut |
700 | 1 | a King, Josiah P. J.u University of Edinburgh4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kolb, Vanessa S.u University of Rhode Island4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kolodziej, Sabinau Kozminski University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kovacs, Martonu Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Krasuska, Karolinau Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kraus, Sueu Fort Lewis College4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Krueger, Lacy E.u Texas A&M University – Commerce4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Kuchno, Katarzynau Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Lage, Caio Ambrosiou Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Langford, Eleanoru University of Virginia4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Walker, Ryan J.u Miami University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Weissgerber, Sophia C.u University of Kassel4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Loy, Jia E.u University of Edinburgh4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Manfredi, Dylanu University of Pennsylvania (United States, Philadelphia)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Levitan, Carmel A.u Occidental College (United States, Los Angeles)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Souza de Lima, Tiago Jesseu Universidade de Brasília4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Lin, Hauseu University of Toronto4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Lins, Samuelu University of Porto4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Markiewicz, Lukaszu Kozminski University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Menon, Madhaviu Nova Southeastern University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Mercier, Brettu University of California, Irvine4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Metzger, Mitchellu Ashland University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Meyet, Venusu Brigham Young University - Idaho4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Millen, Ailsa E.u University of Stirling4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Moore, Don A.u University of California, Berkeley (United States, Berkeley) - UCB4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Muda, Rafalu Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Nave, Gideonu University of Pennsylvania (United States, Philadelphia)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Nichols, Austin Leeu Duy Tan University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Miller, Jeremy K.u Willamette University (United States, Salem)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Montealegre, Andresu Cornell University (United States, Ithaca) - CU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Wiggins, Bradford J.u Brigham Young University - Idaho4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Wolf, Danielu University of Bamberg4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Wichman, Aaron L.u Western Kentucky University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Palinkas, Annau Eötvös Loránd University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Panno, Angelou Sapienza University of Rome4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Parks, Kimberly P.u University of Virginia4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Novak, Sarah A.u Hofstra University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Nunnally, Christianu Rose–Hulman Institute of Technology4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Orlic, Anau University of Belgrade4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Pfeiffer, Thomasu Massey University (New Zealand, Palmerston North)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Pedovic, Ivanau University of Nis4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Pekala, Emilianu Maria Curie-Skłodowska University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Penner, Matthew R.u Western Kentucky University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Pessers, Sebastiaanu KU Leuven4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Petrovic, Bobanu University of Belgrade4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Buttrick, Nicholas R.u University of Virginia4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Chartier, Christopher R.u Ashland University (United States, Ashland) - AU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Corker, Katherine S.u Grand Valley State University (United States, Allendale) - GVSU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Hartshorne, Joshua K.u Boston College (United States, Boston) - BC4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Corley, Martinu University of Edinburgh (United Kingdom, Edinburgh)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a IJzerman, Hansu Institut Universitaire de France (France, Paris) - IUF4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Lazarevic, Ljiljana B.u University of Belgrade (Serbia, Belgrade)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Rabagliati, Hughu University of Edinburgh (United Kingdom, Edinburgh)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ropovik, Ivanu Charles University (Czechia, Prague)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Aczel, Balazsu Eötvös Loránd University (Hungary, Budapest) - ELTE4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Aeschbach, Lena F.u University of Basel (Switzerland, Basel)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Andrighetto, Lucau University of Genoa (Italy, Genoa) - UniGe4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Arnal, Jack D.u McDaniel College (United States, Westminster)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Arrow, Hollyu University of Oregon (United States, Eugene) - UO4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bruehlmann, Florianu University of Basel4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Brumbaugh, Claudia C.u Queens College, CUNY4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Casini, Ericau University of Milano-Bicocca4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Chen, Yilingu Harvard University (United States, Cambridge)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Chiorri, Carlou University of Genoa4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Babincak, Peteru University of Prešov (Slovakia, Prešov)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bakos, Bence E.u Eötvös Loránd University (Hungary, Budapest) - ELTE4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Banik, Gabrielu University of Prešov (Slovakia, Prešov)4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Baskin, Ernestu Saint Joseph's University (United States, Philadelphia) - SJU4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Belopavlovic, Radomiru University of Novi Sad4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bernstein, Michael H.u Brown University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bialek, Michalu University of Wrocław4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bloxsom, Nicholas G.u Ashland University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bodroza, Bojanau University of Novi Sad4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Bonfiglio, Diane B.u Ashland University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Boucher, Leanneu Nova Southeastern University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Chopik, William J.u Michigan State University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Christ, Oliveru Hagen4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Ciunci, Antonia M.u University of Rhode Island4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Claypool, Heather M.u Miami University4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Coary, Seanu Loyola University Chicago4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Colic, Marijau University of Belgrade4 aut |
700 | 1 | a Collins, W. Matthewu Nova Southeastern University4 aut |
710 | 2 | a University of Virginia (United States, Charlottesville) - UVAb Stanford University (United States, Stanford) - SU4 org |
773 | 0 | t Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Scienced : Sageg 3:3, s. 309-331q 3:3<309-331x 2515-2467x 2515-2459 |
856 | 4 | u https://research.hhs.se/esploro/outputs/journalArticle/Many-Labs-5-Testing-Pre-Data-Collection-Peer/991001489599306056x primaryx Object in context |
856 | 4 | u https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/2515245920958687 |
856 | 4 8 | u https://research.hhs.se/esploro/outputs/journalArticle/Many-Labs-5-Testing-Pre-Data-Collection-Peer/991001489599306056 |
856 | 4 8 | u https://doi.org/10.1177/2515245920958687 |
Kungliga biblioteket hanterar dina personuppgifter i enlighet med EU:s dataskyddsförordning (2018), GDPR. Läs mer om hur det funkar här.
Så här hanterar KB dina uppgifter vid användning av denna tjänst.
Kopiera och spara länken för att återkomma till aktuell vy